ive been using this eyeliner since july 2007, its my holy grail eyeliner
ive tried many black eyeliners but i always go back to this
its a retractable eyeliner w/ a built in sharpener
i use this liner in my waterline, i tightline with it, and i apply on upper lash line and with a liner brush blend/smudge into shadow to darken and create a more subtle line (it gives enough time to work with it before drying)
it is long lasting, i never find myself needing to reapply, very minimal (unwanted) smudging on lower lash line (& i dont notice that till end of the day)
its intense black exactly what i look for
ive never had any issues with the product, but i will say that i find it often out of stock in black atleast, which has caused me to try other liners but nothing ive found so far can compare to this, i even choose this over the UD zero liner which i also own
i recommend this for anyone looking for a new eyeliner, its amazing, it may not work on everyone, were all different as far as what will stay on our waterline, ive tried liners that last on others but not myself thats why i just want to add that
the liner without cap
the liner swatched, & smudged (see how the lines still very much intact)
if you try this out, let me know what you think(:i will be doing reviews on other lines at some point since ive tried sooo many



